Should US Be Required to Provide Illegal Transgender Detainees With Hormone Replacement Therapy?

Question by Chavie: Should US be required to provide illegal Transgender detainees with hormone replacement therapy?
SANTA ANA In the depths of depression, battling hot flashes and desperate about her situation, Monica Freas tried to throw herself from the second floor of the Santa Ana Jail before friends restrained her.
After two decades of taking hormone replacement therapy, the 35-year-old no longer had access to the drugs that made her feel comfortable in her own skin. She begged and pleaded with jailers for months to give her the medication that made her “feel normal,” but they refused.
“I just can’t even look at myself in the mirror anymore,” Freas said in a recent interview while in detention on suspicion of being in the country illegally. She rubbed her face and pointed to the stubble on her cheeks. “For years I tried hard to get to that point and for it all to be taken away.”
She and others have shared their stories with the Heartland Alliance National Immigrant Justice Center, an advocacy group that has filed complaints with the Department of Homeland Security alleging that jailers nationwide have deprived detainees of “adequate health care” by denying them the therapy.
Immigrant-rights groups, the American Medical Association and others in the medical community say hormone replacement therapy is necessary in cases of gender identity disorder. Those with the disorder feel a strong identification with the opposite sex, which causes intense emotional pain and suffering, according to the National Institutes of Health.
Others question whether taxpayers should fund the treatment for a certain population of immigration detainees. While immigration officials say they don’t know the exact cost of providing hormone therapy to detainees, at least one physician puts the price tag at about $ 1,000 per person per year for treatment and monitoring.
It is unclear how many transgender detainees make up the estimated daily immigration detention population of more than 30,000 at nationwide facilities because Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials don’t track such figures, said ICE spokeswoman Virginia Kice. The Santa Ana Jail now houses about 40 transgender detainees as part of a contract with ICE.
Over the past few months, Santa Ana Jail has become the primary host for vulnerable and special needs ICE detainees – including transgender detainees – for the Los Angeles area, ICE officials said. The transgender detainees are separated from the regular inmate population for their own safety, officials added.
Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies, an anti-illegal immigration think tank, said taxpayers shouldn’t have to pay for the treatment.
“It’s one thing if you have a medication that is necessary for you to continue breathing,” he said. “It’s not what this is.”

Best answer:

Answer by Anti Censorship
No, thats like requiring the US to provide drugs to drug addicts. What that person is doing isn’t essential to their survival so the state is no way obligated to provide it.

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!



Take the certification course in Auricular (Ear) Acupuncture at Brighton Hospital in Michigan – Auricular Acupuncture Training in Michigan. Brighton Hospital in Michigan is America’s second oldest Addiction Treatment Center, offering detoxification, rehabilitation, inpatient, outpatient and aftercare services for alcoholism and substance abuse. Brighton’s Integrative Therapies Department is now a major training center for the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA) certification course in Auricular detox acupuncture. Virginia June, LMSW, CAAC, RT, leads Brighton’s three-day certification course, which prepares individuals for the practice of auricular (ear) acupuncture, which has been shown to be effective and harmless in the treatment of addictions. In this video, NADA certified acupuncture instructor Virginia June describes the course in auricular acupuncture and summarizes the value of these treatments for addicts and recovering individuals. Virginia June is director of Integrative Therapies at Brighton Hospital in Michigan and has decades of experience as a therapist in the field of addictions.


Virginia horse euthanized for West Nile Virus

Filed under: drug treatment centers in virginia

"In Virginia, the mosquito season often runs through November, " Lidolm says. "And last year was such a mild winter, it never really stopped." Currently, no drugs exist to specifically treat West Nile Virus in horses or humans. According to the Centers …
Read more on WTOP


Scores of recent Texas war veterans have died of overdoses, suicide and

Filed under: drug treatment centers in virginia

He died in September 2010 with a half-dozen prescription drugs in his system, including anti-anxiety medication and powerful painkillers oxycodone and methadone prescribed by physicians in a private pain clinic and VA doctors. Mitchell suffered from …
Read more on Austin American-Statesman


Treatment Facility Offers "Much Easier Detoxification Process"

Filed under: drug treatment centers in virginia

After going through programs and learning more about what addiction was, his group has found their own way to treat people without having to use other drugs like Suboxone on Methadone. The treatment facility is located in Richmond, Virginia and has …
Read more on WDTV


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *